Palestinians in Ukraine criticize Kyiv’s ‘double standard’ in supporting Israel : Analysis

When Russia launched a full-scale war on Ukraine on February 24, 2022, Amer Aroggi, a 30-year-old journalist based in the Gaza Strip, felt compelled to report on the European conflict. Having lived through the Israeli occupation, he felt he could relate to the plight of the Ukrainians.

Aroggi quickly secured a new role for himself as a correspondent for a prominent news channel, leveraging his connections in Ukraine. However, when war broke out again in Gaza with the latest escalation of the Israel-Palestine conflict, Aroggi was shocked by the Ukrainian response.

Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy threw his support behind Israel, leaving Aroggi feeling abandoned and betrayed. He saw a double standard at play, with Ukraine receiving support during their conflict with Russia while Gaza was left to suffer alone.

This support for Israel was influenced by a prevailing pro-Israel narrative in the national media, which aligns with the sentiments of many Ukrainians. However, some Ukrainians have begun openly criticizing their government’s position, especially as they witness the death and destruction in Gaza.

In November, over 300 Ukrainian scholars, activists, and artists expressed their solidarity with Palestinians in an open letter. This letter emphasized the right of Palestinians to self-determination and resistance against Israel’s occupation, drawing parallels to Ukraine’s resistance against the Russian invasion.

There has been a gradual shift in public opinion as more Ukrainians begin to view the Israeli narrative as false and unfair. Mounting pressure from pro-Palestinian segments of society has also influenced the Ukrainian government’s position, with Ukraine backing a UN resolution urging the International Court of Justice to provide an opinion on the legal consequences of Israel’s occupation of Palestinian territories.

However, there is still significant support for Israel among Ukrainian political liberals who view Israel as a democratic and progressive nation. The level of knowledge about Palestine and its history has started to increase in Ukraine, thanks to leading opinion makers and intellectuals providing context about Ukraine’s historical support for Palestine and the Israeli occupation.

Images depicting the horrors of Israel’s bombardment of Gaza have created a sense of empathy among Ukrainians, who now see parallels with their own experiences of war. Overall, there has been a shift in public opinion and a change in tone among government officials, with Ukrainian President Zelenskyy recognizing the independence of both the Israeli and Palestinian people in December.

Analysis:
The article discusses the evolving perspective of Ukraine towards the Israeli-Palestinian conflict and the influence of media, public opinion, and government officials on this shift. However, there are several factors to consider when evaluating the reliability of the information presented.

Firstly, the credibility of the sources is not mentioned. The article does not cite specific news outlets or journalists, making it difficult to assess the trustworthiness of the information. Additionally, the author’s personal experience as a journalist in the Gaza Strip is mentioned, but there is no indication of their expertise or qualifications on the subject.

Secondly, the presentation of facts in the article is limited. While it mentions the Ukrainian government’s support for Israel during the conflict with Russia, it does not provide specific examples or quotes to support this claim. The article also mentions an open letter signed by over 300 Ukrainian scholars, activists, and artists expressing solidarity with Palestinians, but it does not provide further details or discuss any opposing viewpoints.

Potential biases are present in the article. The author mentions a “prevailing pro-Israel narrative” in the Ukrainian media without providing evidence or examples. This suggests a bias against the Ukrainian media, framing their support for Israel as unfair. The article also mentions a “mounting pressure” from pro-Palestinian segments of society influencing the Ukrainian government’s position, but it does not provide any evidence or context for this claim.

As for the impact of the information presented, it is difficult to determine its reliability and influence without additional context and evidence from credible sources. The article suggests a shift in public opinion and a change in tone among government officials, but it does not provide concrete examples or data to support this claim. It is unclear how representative the mentioned Ukrainian scholars, activists, and artists are of the overall Ukrainian population.

Considering the prevalence of fake news and the political landscape, it is important for the public to critically evaluate the information they consume. Without proper sourcing and balanced analysis, articles like this one can contribute to misinformation or a one-sided understanding of the topic. The political landscape and the prevalence of fake news can further influence the public’s perception by reinforcing existing biases or creating echo chambers where opposing viewpoints are not adequately represented.

Source: Aljazeera news: Palestinians in Ukraine decry ‘double standard’ as Kyiv supports Israel

0

0